Pier House Resort & Spa vs Nearby Hotels
Considering Pier House Resort & Spa but want to compare other hotels nearby? These guides show how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against popular alternatives.
Updated · 19 comparisons
All 19 Pier House Resort & Spa Comparisons

Pier House Resort & Spa vs Ocean Key Resort A Noble House Resort
Pier House: beachfront family resort with a large spa; Ocean Key: compact waterfront luxury at Mallory Square.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Hyatt Centric Key West Resort and Spa
Pier House: Old Town beachfront & large spa. Hyatt Centric: marina‑front, branded stay near Duval.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection
Pier House at Duval Street: spa, private beach and Old Town access; Casa Marina: historic Curio beachfront with larger meeting space.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs The Reach Key West, Curio Collection
Pier House: Old Town oceanfront with a full-service spa; The Reach: Hilton Curio beachfront near Duval — both beachfront and walkable.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Margaritaville Beach House Key West
Pier House is Old Town historic waterfront with a large spa; Margaritaville Beach House is a casual, family-friendly beachfront stay near Smathers Beach.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs The Marker Key West Harbor Resort
Pier House: classic oceanfront with private beach and large spa; The Marker: modern harborfront with three pools and balcony rooms.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Parrot Key Hotel & Villas
Pier House: Old Town beachfront, private beach and a large spa. Parrot Key: waterfront cottages, multiple pools and resort-style grounds.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses
Pier House — historic oceanfront spa resort at 1 Duval St. Southernmost — larger beachfront complex near the Southernmost Point.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs La Concha Key West, Autograph Collection
Pier House has a private beach and large spa; La Concha is a historic Duval Street Marriott boutique hotel.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Hilton Key West Resort & Marina
Pier House: Old Town beachfront with private sand and a big spa; Hilton Key West: marina resort with many pools and brand amenities.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West
Pier House: Old Town beachfront and a large full-service spa. The Perry: modern marina resort on Stock Island with docks and pools.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Havana Cabana at Key West
Pier House: Old Town oceanfront and full-service spa. Havana Cabana: Cuban-style, pool-focused New Town stay.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs The Gates Hotel Key West
Pier House: Old Town beachfront resort with private beach and full-service spa; The Gates: modern New Town lifestyle hotel.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs DoubleTree Resort
Pier House is the Old Town, beachfront spa option; DoubleTree is a larger Hilton-brand resort with conference space and shuttle service.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs The Gardens Hotel
Pier House: oceanfront resort with private beach, spa and multiple restaurants. The Gardens Hotel: small luxury hotel with garden pools and included breakfast.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Eden House
Pier House is the oceanfront resort with a large spa and private beach; Eden House is a small, classic Key West inn near Duval.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Winslow's Bungalows Key West Historic Inns
Pier House Resort & Spa: oceanfront resort with private beach and full-service spa; Winslow’s Bungalows: boutique bungalow-style Historic Inn in Old Town.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection
Pier House is a beachfront full‑service resort with a big spa and family focus; The Saint is a small adults-only Autograph boutique near Duval Street.
Compare →
Pier House Resort & Spa vs Orchid Key Inn
Pier House: oceanfront resort with private beach and large spa; Orchid Key Inn: adults-only boutique on Duval Street.
Compare →Includes private beach access
- Lowest rate guarantee
- Complimentary perks & upgrades
- 24/7 concierge