
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for beach-first stays, Old Town sightseeing and an on-site, full-service spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a four-star, family-friendly oceanfront resort on Old Town’s Duval Street with a private white-sand beach and a full-service spa. The Gates Hotel Key West is a four-star contemporary lifestyle hotel in New Town geared toward travelers who want a larger, modern property outside the historic center.
Updated · about 3.8 km apart

Best for beach-first stays, Old Town sightseeing and an on-site, full-service spa.

Best for travelers who prefer a modern, larger hotel outside Old Town with practical amenities and easy access to the airport and New Town attractions.
Pier House Resort & Spa wins if you want true beachfront access in Old Town, immediate walking access to Duval Street and Mallory Square, multiple on-site restaurants and a substantial on-site spa.
The Gates Hotel Key West wins if you prefer a contemporary, larger hotel footprint in New Town with practical facilities (fitness, business center, pool) and easier access to the airport and New Town sights.
Bottom line: pick Pier House for Old Town beach-and-spa experience; pick The Gates for a modern, convenient base outside the historic district.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | The Gates Hotel Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Classic Old Town oceanfront resort with island-styled rooms and historic bar | Contemporary lifestyle hotel with modern public spaces |
| Location | 1 Duval St, Old Town Key West — steps from Duval Street and Mallory Square, private white-sand beach on site | 3824 N Roosevelt Blvd, New Town — at the entrance to Key West (New Town), closer to Key West Intl. Airport |
| Size / rooms | About 142 rooms and suites across low-rise buildings (mix of oceanfront rooms and suites) | 100 air-conditioned rooms (listing), room types include Double Room, single room - king, ADA King |
| Ages / audience | All ages welcome; primary guest must be at least 24 to check in | All ages welcome; property check-in min age listed as 21 in supplier policies |
| Pools & beach | Heated outdoor pool, fenced family-friendly pool area, whirlpool hot tub and private white-sand beach | Outdoor pool (1) with poolside bar and access to a nearby outdoor pool noted; no private beach listed |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: One Duval (oceanfront dinner), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café | Two restaurants and a coffee shop/cafe; poolside bar and bar/lounge; one coffee shop/cafe listed |
| Spa & wellness | Pier House Spa — ~10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, steam room, Vichy showers, signature massages and facials, 24-hour fitness center | Fitness facilities on site; spa/beauty services noted as 'nearby' rather than an on-site full-service spa |
| Known for | Old Town beachfront location, historic Chart Room Bar and an on-site full-service spa | Contemporary lifestyle positioning at Key West's New Town entrance and practical amenities for travelers |
| Accessibility & family features | Family-friendly amenities, in-room cribs available, fenced pool; pet policy allows dogs up to 40 lbs (one per room) for a fee | Wheelchair-accessible features throughout, accessible pool, family stay policies allow children to stay free using existing bedding |
| Practical extras | Mandatory resort fee (published $62), on-site parking (secure lot) with nightly charge, cashless property | Self parking (surcharge), shuttle (surcharge), business center, dry cleaning, free Wi‑Fi |
Pier House sits at 1 Duval Street in Old Town with direct access to a private white-sand beach and immediate walking access to Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Choose Pier House when you want Old Town walkability and beachfront access without a car.
The Gates Hotel Key West is in New Town near the entrance to Key West, a short ride from Key West Intl. Airport and New Town attractions.
Pick The Gates for easier airport access and a base outside the busiest Old Town area.
Pier House offers a range of coastal rooms and suites including multiple oceanfront categories and family-friendly suites.
Pick Pier House for oceanfront rooms and larger suite options suitable for families.
The Gates offers modern, air‑conditioned rooms in a larger New Town hotel with standard conveniences.
Choose The Gates for straightforward, modern rooms and accessible room types.
Pier House centers its dining around oceanfront One Duval plus casual beach and cafe outlets.
Pier House suits travelers seeking waterfront, varied dining within walking distance of Old Town nightlife.
The Gates lists two restaurants plus a coffee shop/cafe and a poolside bar in its supplier listing.
The Gates provides practical on-site dining options for a modern hotel stay outside Old Town.
Pier House’s headline amenity is its private white-sand beach complemented by a heated outdoor pool and whirlpool.
If beach access matters most, Pier House is the clear choice.
The Gates has an outdoor pool and poolside bar but does not list a private beach on its supplier listing.
The Gates is good if you want a hotel pool in a modern setting, but not a beachfront property.
Pier House’s spa and historic Chart Room Bar are major draws for guests wanting relaxation and local nightlife.
Pick Pier House if you value a large on-site spa plus historic bar atmosphere.
The Gates emphasizes contemporary public spaces and fitness facilities over an on-site full-service spa.
The Gates fits travelers who want modern hotel fitness and social spaces rather than a destination spa.

Pier House — private white-sand beach and immediate walkability to Duval Street and Mallory Square.

The Gates — contemporary hotel layout with practical amenities and closer proximity to the airport.

Pier House — an on-site, large full-service spa with multiple signature treatments and facilities.

The Gates — many wheelchair-accessible features, accessible pool and accessible public washrooms.
Pier House is on Duval Street in Old Town and is within easy walking distance of many Old Town attractions; The Gates sits in New Town and requires a short drive or shuttle to reach Old Town.
Pier House has a private white-sand beach on site. The Gates does not list a private beach in its supplier listing.
Pier House Spa requires guests to be at least 14 to receive treatments. The Gates’ listing notes health or beauty spa nearby rather than an on-site full-service spa.
Yes. Pier House is explicitly family-friendly (children of all ages welcome, though primary guest must be at least 24 to check in). The Gates’ supplier listing allows children and notes up to two children 17 and under stay free using existing bedding.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·