
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want a historic, slightly more polished waterfront property with a large on-site spa and immediate access to Old Town/Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a historic, waterfront Key West resort with a private white-sand beach, a full-service spa and direct access to Old Town attractions; read this if you want a refined, stay-on-site waterfront experience near Duval Street. Margaritaville Beach House Key West is a casual, island-branded beachfront resort on South Roosevelt Boulevard for travelers who want laid-back, family-friendly Margaritaville-style amenities and easy access to Smathers Beach.
Updated · about 3.3 km apart

Best for travelers who want a historic, slightly more polished waterfront property with a large on-site spa and immediate access to Old Town/Duval Street.

Best for families and Margaritaville fans who want a relaxed, recognizable brand experience close to Smathers Beach with many room configurations.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: choose Pier House if you value Old Town location steps from Duval Street, a private white-sand beach on site, and a large full-service spa (10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms).
When Margaritaville Beach House Key West wins: pick Margaritaville if you want a more casual, family-oriented brand experience, more room-type variety/suite inventory, complimentary airport shuttle (on request) and a pool + poolside bar near Smathers Beach.
Bottom line: Pier House is the more refined, history-forward waterfront choice in Old Town with spa focus; Margaritaville Beach House is the relaxed, brand-driven pick on the south shore for families and fans of Margaritaville’s casual vibe.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | Margaritaville Beach House Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic, waterfront-refined with an emphasis on spa and Old Town access | Casual, island-themed Margaritaville brand; family-friendly and relaxed |
| Location | 1 Duval Street, Old Town — steps from Duval Street and Mallory Square; private beach on site | 2001 South Roosevelt Blvd — by the ocean and a short drive to Smathers Beach |
| Size / rooms | 142 rooms total (119 guest rooms + 23 suites) across low-rise buildings | 186 rooms (multiple suite and accessible configurations) |
| Family / age policy | All ages welcome; booking adult must be at least 24 to check in | All ages welcome; adultsOnly: false |
| Pools & beach | Heated outdoor pool, fenced family-friendly pool area, private white-sand beach, whirlpool hot tub | Outdoor pool, hot tub, poolside bar; property is by the ocean near Smathers Beach |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site outlets: One Duval (oceanfront seafood/dinner), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café | One on-site restaurant and bar offerings, plus poolside bar and room service during limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Pier House Spa — roughly 10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, steam room, Vichy showers; 24-hour fitness center | Not published |
| Accessibility & family services | Family rooms, in-room cribs, fenced pool; pet policy allows dogs up to 40 lbs (one per room) for a fee | Extensive accessibility features listed (accessible rooms, pool hoist, accessible parking); babysitting/childcare (surcharge) |
| Meeting & event space | Multiple event venues including Grand Cayman Ballroom (2,000 sq ft) and beachfront terraces; wedding capacity up to 120 | Number of meeting rooms: 3 (banquet/meeting spaces available) |
| Airport transfer | Nearest airport Key West Intl. Airport (EYW) — a short taxi/rideshare to Old Town; resort mentions shuttle and valet services covered by resort fee | Roundtrip airport shuttle is complimentary (available on request) |
Pier House sits at 1 Duval Street in Old Town with immediate access to Duval Street, Mallory Square and other Old Town attractions, plus a private white-sand beach on site.
Pick Pier House if you want to be in the heart of Old Town with a private beach and immediate waterfront dining.
Margaritaville Beach House Key West sits on South Roosevelt Boulevard near Smathers Beach, positioned for beach access on the south shore of Key West.
Choose Margaritaville if you prefer south-shore beach access and a resort near Smathers Beach rather than Old Town walking proximity.
Pier House offers 142 rooms and suites with coastal décor, many with balconies or patios and family-friendly bedding setups.
If you want oceanfront historic rooms with multiple suite choices and an on-site spa focus, Pier House’s room mix fits well.
Margaritaville Beach House has 186 air-conditioned rooms and suites in a variety of resort, pool and ocean-facing configurations.
Margaritaville offers a larger room inventory and many suite options, useful for families or groups needing flexible configurations.
Pier House provides a range from oceanfront fine-casual seafood to beach-bar fare and a historic bar with live music.
Pier House suits travelers who want both refined waterfront dinners and informal beach-bar options without leaving the property.
Margaritaville’s outlets are consistent with its casual island brand: restaurant, bar and poolside bar with room service (limited hours).
Margaritaville is the simpler, brand-driven dining option focused on casual, family-friendly meals and poolside service.
Pier House has a heated outdoor pool, a fenced family-friendly pool area, a whirlpool hot tub and a private white-sand beach.
Pier House combines a small heated pool and an on-site private beach — good for guests who want a waterfront beach day plus pool time.
Margaritaville offers an outdoor pool with a poolside bar and a hot tub, and is located by the ocean with easy access to Smathers Beach nearby.
Margaritaville is aimed at casual pool-and-beach days and brand-style leisure rather than Old Town waterfront dining experiences.
Pier House emphasizes wellness with a large full-service spa and a 24-hour fitness center; nightlife centers on the Chart Room and Old Town.
If spa treatments and an evening bar with local history matter, Pier House is the stronger pick.
Margaritaville focuses on casual relaxation with typical resort entertainment and fitness offerings; specifics on a large spa are not published in supplier data.
Margaritaville works for travelers who want straightforward resort fitness and poolside socializing; it does not publish a large dedicated full-service spa like Pier House.

Pier House — steps from Duval Street, Mallory Square and Old Town museums, plus its own private white-sand beach.

Pier House — the Pier House Spa is roughly 10,000 sq ft with 10 treatment rooms and multiple spa amenities.

Margaritaville Beach House Key West — larger room count (186) and many 1- and 2-bedroom suite configurations.

Margaritaville — laid-back Margaritaville-branded atmosphere, poolside bar and easy access to Smathers Beach.
Pier House — it sits at the foot of Duval Street and is within easy walking distance of restaurants, bars and Mallory Square.
Yes — Margaritaville Beach House Key West publishes a complimentary roundtrip airport shuttle available on request.
Pier House — the Pier House Spa is a large, published full-service facility (~10,000 sq ft with 10 treatment rooms). Margaritaville’s listing does not publish a comparable full-service spa.
No. Both properties welcome guests of all ages; neither is published as adults-only.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·