
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want a small, historic oceanfront hotel steps from Mallory Square, Duval Street nightlife, and a sizeable spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a compact, historic oceanfront resort at 1 Duval Street with a private white-sand beach and a large full-service spa; read this if you want a central, walkable Old Town base with waterfront dining and spa facilities. Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses is a larger beachfront resort complex near the Southernmost Point buoy; read this if you want a bigger property on the southern end of Duval with direct beach access and resort-style facilities.
Updated · about 1.2 miles apart

Best for travelers who want a small, historic oceanfront hotel steps from Mallory Square, Duval Street nightlife, and a sizeable spa.

Best for travelers seeking a larger beachfront resort complex closer to the Southernmost Point marker with a broader set of room types and resort facilities.
When Pier House wins: choose Pier House if you want to be at the foot of Duval Street, prefer a small property with direct private white-sand beach access, and value its dedicated 10,000 sq ft spa and waterfront dining options.
When Southernmost wins: pick Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses if you prefer a bigger resort complex on the southern end of Key West near the Southernmost Point buoy, more varied room-type inventory, and multiple on-site amenities like a fitness center, outdoor pool and on-site restaurants/bars.
Bottom line: both are beachfront, family-friendly resorts in Old Town Key West; Pier House is the smaller, historic, spa-forward option right at Duval’s start, while Southernmost is a larger, straightforward beachfront resort complex nearer the Southernmost Point.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Compact, historic oceanfront resort with waterfront dining and spa focus | Larger beachfront resort complex with broad facility list |
| Location in Key West | Foot of Duval Street, steps from Mallory Square and Old Town attractions | Southern end of Duval Street near the Southernmost Point buoy |
| Size (rooms & suites) | 142 guest rooms and suites (mix of rooms and suites) | Not published |
| Age policy / audience | All ages welcome; primary check-in age 24; family‑friendly | All ages welcome; family-friendly resort complex |
| Pools & beach | Heated outdoor pool, whirlpool hot tub, private white-sand beach on site | Outdoor swimming pool(s) and direct beach access |
| Restaurants & bars | One Duval (oceanfront dinner), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café | On-site restaurants and bars; multiple dining options listed |
| Spa & fitness | Pier House Spa — ~10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, steam room, Vichy showers; 24-hour fitness center | Spa and massage services listed; fitness center available |
| Known for | Historic Chart Room Bar, private white-sand beach, large dedicated spa | Beachfront location close to Southernmost Point and family-friendly resort amenities |
| Nearby highlights | Duval Street, Mallory Square, Key West Aquarium within a short walk | Southernmost Museum, Southernmost Point buoy, Key West Butterfly & Nature Conservatory nearby |
| Resort fee & extras | Mandatory resort fee (includes high-speed Wi-Fi); on-site parking (surcharge) | Complimentary Wi‑Fi in rooms; on-site parking available (charges apply) |
Pier House sits at the foot of Duval Street in Old Town, a short walk to Mallory Square and many attractions.
Best if you want to be centrally located on Duval and close to Old Town landmarks.
Southernmost Beach Resort & Guesthouses occupies a larger beachfront parcel near the Southernmost Point marker at the southern end of Duval.
Best if you want beachfront access near the Southernmost Point and a quieter end of Duval.
Pier House has a mix of standard rooms and multiple suite categories including oceanfront suites and multi-bedroom options.
Best for travelers seeking classic oceanfront rooms and family suites with beachfront access.
Southernmost lists many room types across a larger resort complex, from Cozy Queen to multi-bedroom residences.
Best if you want a wider range of room categories and some apartment/suite-style options.
Pier House emphasizes waterfront dining with One Duval as the signature oceanfront restaurant and multiple casual options.
Best if you want distinct waterfront venues and a range from casual to more formal oceanfront dining.
Southernmost offers on-site restaurants and bars for resort-style dining without leaving the property.
Best if you want convenient on-site meal options across a larger resort footprint.
Pier House has a private white-sand beach plus a heated outdoor pool and whirlpool hot tub.
Best if a private beach and a heated pool matter to your stay.
Southernmost is explicitly presented as a beachfront resort with at least outdoor pool(s) and beach access.
Best if you prioritize staying on the beach at a larger resort property rather than a private-beach boutique setup.
Pier House focuses on a sizable full-service spa plus a 24-hour fitness center and the Chart Room Bar for evening energy.
Best if you plan to use a larger on-site spa and still want close evening entertainment on Duval.
Southernmost lists spa and massage services and a fitness center among its amenities.
Best if you want standard resort wellness facilities without the specificity of a large dedicated spa.

Pier House — a large dedicated spa (≈10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms) and spa treatments on site.

Pier House — sits at the foot of Duval Street and is a short walk to Mallory Square and Old Town attractions.

Southernmost — larger resort complex at the southern end of Duval with direct beach access and many room types.

Southernmost — wide room-type list from Cozy Queen to The Residence three-bedroom suites.
Pier House is at the foot of Duval Street and is the closer choice for Mallory Square and Old Town nightlife.
Pier House has a large, roughly 10,000 sq ft spa with 10 treatment rooms; Southernmost lists spa and massage services but does not publish a comparable spa size.
Pier House advertises a private white-sand beach on site. Southernmost advertises direct beach access but the supplier listing does not use the word 'private.'
Yes. Both properties are family-friendly and accept guests of all ages.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·