
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who prioritize a large spa, historic on-site bar and multiple dining venues right at the foot of Duval Street.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a four-star, family-friendly oceanfront resort at 1 Duval Street with a large on-site spa and historic Chart Room bar; read this if you want Old Town history, a full spa program, and direct access to a private white-sand beach. The Reach Key West, Curio Collection is a four-star, Hilton-affiliated beachfront Curio Collection property on Simonton Street; read this if you want a Hilton-branded beachfront stay close to Duval but with a smaller, design-forward footprint.
Updated · about 0.5 km apart

Best for travelers who prioritize a large spa, historic on-site bar and multiple dining venues right at the foot of Duval Street.

Best for travelers who want a Hilton Curio beachfront property with direct beach access and a compact, walkable location near Old Town attractions.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: choose Pier House if you want the biggest on-site spa in Key West, a mix of dining options (One Duval, Three Palms, Chart Room, Harbour View Café), and a property with explicit family-friendly services and room types that accommodate groups and families.
When The Reach Key West, Curio Collection wins: choose The Reach if you prefer staying at a Hilton Curio beachfront property with straightforward beachfront access, a smaller resort footprint and easy access to Simonton/Lower Duval area while keeping Hilton loyalty benefits.
Bottom line: both are upscale, beachfront Key West options within a short walk of Duval Street; pick Pier House for spa-focused stays, history and more dining/venue choices, pick The Reach for a Hilton Curio beachfront style and a compact resort experience.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | The Reach Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic Old Town oceanfront resort with a mix of family-friendly and romantic spaces | Upscale, Hilton Curio beachfront resort with a design-forward, compact feel |
| Location | 1 Duval Street — at the foot of Duval Street and Mallory Square, private white-sand beach | 1435 Simonton Street — beachfront near southern end of Old Town and within a short walk of Duval |
| Size (rooms & suites) | 142 rooms and suites (119 guest rooms + 23 suites listed across sources) | 150 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / family policy | Family-friendly; children welcome (primary guest must be at least 24 to check in) | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool and fenced whirlpool (dawn–dusk) | One outdoor pool and poolside bar; private beach access |
| Beach | Private white-sand beach on site | On private beach (beachfront) |
| Spa & wellness | Pier House Spa — ~10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, full-service spa and fitness center | Full-service spa on site with reservations required for treatments |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: One Duval (oceanfront dinner), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café | One main restaurant (Four Marlins) plus poolside bar and limited room service |
| Meetings & events | Multiple event rooms including Grand Cayman Ballroom (2,000 sq ft) and beach/terrace venues | Conference space ~4 meeting rooms and 4,700 sq ft of event space |
| On-property activities | Water-sports arrangements, fitness center, spa treatments, evening entertainment at Chart Room | Kayaking, sailing, snorkeling nearby, poolside bar and concierge-arranged excursions |
Pier House sits at 1 Duval Street in Old Town, steps from Mallory Square and Duval Street with a private white-sand beach.
Choose Pier House for the most central Old Town location and immediate access to Duval and Mallory Square.
The Reach is on Simonton Street, a short walk from Duval and near the southern end of Old Town with direct beachfront access.
Pick The Reach if you want a Hilton Curio beachfront stay a short walk from Duval without being in the busiest blocks.
Pier House offers a range of rooms and suites with coastal décor, many with balconies or patios and options for families.
Pier House is a good fit for families and groups who want suite options and oceanfront rooms right at Duval.
The Reach lists 150 individually decorated guestrooms and a range of resort and ocean/Key West view studios and suites.
The Reach works well for travelers focused on ocean views within a Hilton Curio property and who value a compact resort layout.
Pier House offers multiple on-site venues from fine-dining oceanfront to a casual beach bar and the historic Chart Room.
Choose Pier House if you want a range of on-site dining options spanning fine dining to casual beach fare without leaving the resort.
The Reach has one main restaurant (Four Marlins) plus a poolside bar and limited room service hours.
The Reach suits travelers who want solid on-site dining without many on-property restaurant choices.
Pier House pairs a private white-sand beach with a heated outdoor pool and whirlpool that's family-friendly.
If a private beach plus a family-oriented pool area and waterfront event spaces matter, Pier House is the stronger pick.
The Reach provides a private beachfront and one outdoor pool with poolside bar access.
The Reach is ideal for guests who prioritize immediate beachfront access with a simple pool/beach setup.
Pier House centers wellness around a large dedicated spa and offers nightlife in the Chart Room plus Old Town steps away.
Pier House is the go-to for guests who want an on-site, substantial spa program plus easy Old Town nightlife access.
The Reach has an on-site spa and fitness options and places guests within walking distance of Old Town nightlife.
The Reach balances a quieter resort atmosphere with spa options and quick access to Key West’s evening scene.

Pier House — roughly 10,000 sq ft Pier House Spa with 10 treatment rooms and a wide menu of signature treatments.

The Reach — a Curio Collection (Hilton) beachfront property that combines direct beach access with Hilton Honors benefits.

Pier House — multiple on-site venues from fine dining (One Duval) to a casual beach bar and historic Chart Room.

The Reach — smaller, design-oriented footprint with beachfront access and straightforward amenities.
Both are within easy walking distance of Duval Street; Pier House sits at the foot of Duval while The Reach is a short walk from Duval on Simonton Street.
Pier House is explicitly family-friendly with suite options, in-room cribs and a fenced heated pool; The Reach is all-ages but is presented more as an upscale beachfront Curio property.
Yes. Pier House has a large dedicated spa (Pier House Spa ~10,000 sq ft). The Reach also lists a full-service spa on site; reservations are required for treatments.
Yes. Both Pier House and The Reach list private beach access on their supplier/property information.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·