
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for beach access, family stays, and on-site spa and waterfront dining.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a four-star, family-friendly oceanfront resort with a private white-sand beach, a full-service spa, and multiple on-site restaurants — best for families or travelers who want beach access and a full‑service resort. The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection is a 3.5-star adults-only boutique hotel in Old Town with Marriott Autograph Collection branding — best for couples or adults seeking a stylish, centrally located Duval Street stay.
Updated · about 0.2 miles apart

Best for beach access, family stays, and on-site spa and waterfront dining.

Best for adults-only Old Town stays within steps of Duval Street and a compact boutique feel.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: choose Pier House if you want direct private beach access, a larger resort layout with multiple restaurants and bars, a big spa (roughly 10,000 sq ft with 10 treatment rooms) and family-friendly rooms and policies.
When The Saint wins: pick The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection if you want an adults-only boutique hotel right in the heart of Old Town within very short walks to Duval Street attractions and prefer a smaller, design-forward property with a rooftop terrace and a single bistro.
Bottom line: both are excellent Old Town options; Pier House is the full-service, beachfront resort for families or guests who want more on-site amenities, while The Saint is a compact, adults-only Marriott option for couples and adults who prioritize location and boutique style.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | The Saint Hotel Key West, Autograph Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Resort, relaxed waterfront property with historic bar and family focus. | Adults-only boutique hotel with a modern, design-forward vibe. |
| Location | At the foot of Duval Street with private white-sand beach and waterfront dining. | Centrally located on Eaton Street, steps from Duval Street and Old Town attractions. |
| Size | About 142 guest rooms and suites across low-rise buildings (plus 23 suites). | 36 air-conditioned rooms. |
| Ages | All ages welcome; family-friendly policies and family rooms. | Adults-only property; guests under 18 are not permitted. |
| Pools & beach | Heated outdoor pool, whirlpool hot tub and private white-sand beach onsite. | Outdoor pool (wheelchair-accessible); no private beach on property listed. |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: One Duval (oceanfront fine seafood), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café. | One on-site bistro (Tempt) and a bar/lounge; limited on-site dining options. |
| Spa & fitness | Pier House Spa — ~10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, steam room, Vichy showers; 24-hour fitness center. | Wheelchair-accessible fitness center; no full-service spa published in supplier listing. |
| Known for | Waterfront location, private beach, historic Chart Room Bar, large spa and family offerings. | Adults-only boutique experience, central Old Town location and rooftop terrace. |
| Brand & rating | Independent/resort-branded property; four-star positioning (site), guest rating not published here. | Marriott Autograph Collection, 3.5-star, guest rating 9/10 (supplier listing). |
Pier House sits at One Duval Street in Old Town with private beach and immediate waterfront access.
Choose Pier House if beachfront access and easy waterfront walks are priorities.
The Saint is centrally located at 417 Eaton Street, steps from Duval Street and Old Town attractions.
Choose The Saint for a compact, walkable Old Town base with immediate access to Duval Street nightlife and shopping.
Pier House offers a broad selection of coastal rooms and suites across low-rise buildings.
Pier House fits families and groups needing larger suites and ocean views.
The Saint has a small set of room types typical of a boutique hotel.
The Saint is best if you want a compact, well-appointed room in a boutique setting with accessible options.
Pier House gives multiple on-site dining venues from casual beachfront to oceanfront fine dining.
Pier House suits guests who want a range of on-site dining and evening bar options without leaving property.
The Saint offers a single on-site bistro and a bar/lounge for a more limited, curated dining program.
The Saint fits travelers who plan to eat out in Old Town and want light on-site options.
Pier House’s signature amenities are its private white-sand beach and its full-service spa.
Pier House is the pick for travelers who want on-site beach time plus a large spa and fitness facilities.
The Saint features an outdoor pool and rooftop terrace as its on-site leisure highlights.
The Saint appeals to guests who prioritize a compact hotel with pool and rooftop social spaces rather than a beachfront resort experience.
Pier House blends a full spa, historic bar, and waterfront evening dining for varied nighttime options.
Pier House gives both resort-based evening options and easy access to Old Town nightlife.
The Saint focuses on adults-only nightlife conveniences and proximity to Duval Street.
The Saint is a good base for adults who want to be in the middle of Old Town’s evening scene.

Pier House — private white-sand beach and beachfront dining.

The Saint — adults-only policy and boutique, central Old Town address.

Pier House — large full-service spa with multiple treatment rooms and steam/Vichy features.

The Saint — small property with direct access to Duval Street attractions.
Pier House — it welcomes children of all ages and has family rooms, a fenced pool area, and a private beach. The Saint is adults-only and does not admit guests under 18.
Pier House has a large, full-service Pier House Spa (about 10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms). The Saint’s supplier listing does not publish a full-service spa.
Yes. Both are in Old Town Key West within a very short walk of Duval Street; The Saint is steps from Duval, and Pier House sits at the foot of Duval with waterfront access.
Pier House has multiple on-site venues (oceanfront One Duval, Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café). The Saint has a single bistro (Tempt) and a bar/lounge.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·