
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want Old Town access, a private beach, and an on-site full-service spa.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a historic, oceanfront Key West resort on Duval Street with a private white-sand beach and a full-service spa; read this if you want Old Town walkability and beach access. The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West is a stylish Stock Island marina resort with a modern nautical feel; read this if you prefer a marina base and a quieter, contemporary property outside Old Town.
Updated

Best for travelers who want Old Town access, a private beach, and an on-site full-service spa.

Best for guests who prefer a contemporary marina setting, on-site docks, and a quieter base near Stock Island activities.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: choose Pier House if you want to be in Old Town at the foot of Duval Street, steps from Mallory Square, with a private white-sand beach and a large, full-service spa on site.
When The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West wins: choose The Perry if you want a modern, marina-focused hotel with boat access, on-site docking and two outdoor pools, plus a quieter setting away from Duval Street’s nightlife.
Bottom line: Pier House is the Old Town, beachfront, historic option with a big spa and immediate access to Key West attractions; The Perry is the contemporary marina alternative for water-oriented travelers who don’t need to be on Duval Street.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic oceanfront resort with classic Key West character | Modern, nautical marina resort on Stock Island |
| Location | 1 Duval St, Old Town — walkable to Mallory Square and Duval Street | 7001 Shrimp Road, Stock Island — waterfront on a marina, outside Old Town |
| Size / rooms | 119 guestrooms and 23 suites (142 total rooms across low-rise buildings) | 100 guestrooms |
| Ages / policy | Family-friendly; primary check-in age requirement (24) but children welcome | All-ages property (not adults-only) |
| Pools & water access | Heated outdoor pool, fenced family pool area, private white-sand beach and whirlpool | Two outdoor pools and marina access (docks and boating activities) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple on-site venues: One Duval (oceanfront), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café | Two restaurants and multiple bars; Matt's Stock Island is the signature seafood restaurant on site |
| Spa & wellness | Pier House Spa — roughly 10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, steam room, Vichy showers, fitness center | Fitness center and spa services not published in supplier listing |
| Known for | Private beach, historic Chart Room Bar, Old Town location and large spa | Marina, on-site dock/boat services and modern nautical design |
| Parking & transfers | Self-parking on site (secure lot) for a published fee; resort fee includes some shuttle services | Self-parking available on site (surcharge); self parking and shuttle noted in listing |
| Accessibility & family features | Family rooms, cribs available, fenced pool for families; spa treatments from age 14 | Up to 2 children 16 and under stay free in parent’s room using existing bedding (per listing); connecting rooms available |
Pier House sits at 1 Duval Street in Old Town with direct access to a private white-sand beach and immediate proximity to Duval Street and Mallory Square.
Pick Pier House if you want to be in the middle of Old Town with beach access and walking access to attractions.
The Perry Hotel & Marina Key West sits on Stock Island’s waterfront and emphasizes marina access and a modern, nautical design.
Pick The Perry if you want a marina base and easy access to boats and water activities without staying on Duval Street.
Pier House offers a range of coastal rooms and suites including oceanfront rooms and multi-bedroom suites for families.
Pick Pier House for oceanfront rooms and larger suite options suited to families or those wanting direct ocean views.
The Perry lists a wide set of room names focused on Stock Island, Perry and Mangrove categories and includes studios and suites.
Pick The Perry for modern, marina-facing rooms with many configuration choices and poolside studio options.
Pier House runs multiple venues from a formal oceanfront seafood restaurant to a casual beach bar and a historic Chart Room Bar.
Pick Pier House for a mix of oceanfront fine dining, casual beach fare and an iconic local bar.
The Perry includes two restaurants and bars; the supplier listing highlights Matt’s Stock Island as an on-site seafood option.
Pick The Perry for modern seafood-focused dining and easy access to marina-side casual meals and drinks.
Pier House offers a heated outdoor pool, a whirlpool hot tub, and a private white-sand beach for guests.
Pick Pier House when a private sandy beach and a heated family pool matter most.
The Perry lists two outdoor pools and extensive marina facilities for boating and water-based activities.
Pick The Perry for multiple pools plus direct marina access if boating and dockside activity are priorities.
Pier House features a large full-service Pier House Spa and the historic Chart Room Bar for evening entertainment.
Pick Pier House if an extensive spa program and being close to Old Town nightlife are important.
The Perry emphasizes fitness, marina-side relaxation and quieter evenings by the water rather than Old Town nightlife.
Pick The Perry for fitness access and low-key marina evenings rather than busy Duval Street nightlife.

Pier House puts you at the foot of Duval Street and Mallory Square with immediate walkability to Old Town attractions.

The Perry has on-site docks and marina services for guests who plan to boat, sail or fish from the property.

Pier House Spa is a large, full-service facility with named signature treatments and multiple treatment rooms.

The Perry offers a contemporary marina setting on Stock Island that’s quieter than Old Town.
Pier House is at the foot of Duval Street and is within easy walking distance of Mallory Square and many Old Town attractions.
Pier House Resort & Spa has a private white-sand beach on site; The Perry is a marina property and does not list a private sandy beach.
Pier House has a large, published full-service spa with signature treatments. The Perry’s supplier listing shows fitness facilities but does not publish a full spa program in the provided listing.
Both properties welcome families, but Pier House markets family features explicitly (fenced pool, family suites, cribs) and lists a specific check-in age policy for the booking adult.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·