
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for families and guests who want a private beach plus a full-service spa complex on property.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a historic, family-friendly oceanfront resort at 1 Duval Street with a private white-sand beach and a large on-site spa; read this if you want a beachfront Key West stay with family-friendly rooms and a full spa program. Ocean Key Resort - A Noble House Resort is an iconic upscale waterfront hotel at the top of Duval Street known for sunset-facing rooms and a compact luxury footprint; read this if you prefer a central Old Town waterfront address with easy access to Mallory Square and Duval Street nightlife.
Updated · about 0.1 km apart

Best for families and guests who want a private beach plus a full-service spa complex on property.

Best for travelers who want a small, luxe waterfront hotel right at the top of Duval Street and Mallory Square.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: pick Pier House if you want a private white-sand beach at your doorstep, a large dedicated spa (Pier House Spa) and larger family-friendly suites and event spaces.
When Ocean Key Resort wins: choose Ocean Key if you want a compact, upscale waterfront property steps from Mallory Square, sunset views from many rooms, and a tighter, downtown feel with several bars and a pool focused on socializing.
Bottom line: both are four-star, waterfront Old Town properties within a very short walk of each other; Pier House leans toward beach-and-spa families and larger on-property facilities, while Ocean Key is the smaller, signature sunset-facing luxury option for Old Town activity and nightlife access.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | Ocean Key Resort A Noble House Resort |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Historic oceanfront resort with a resort-feel (private beach, spa, multiple buildings) | Iconic, compact upscale waterfront hotel focused on sunset views and Old Town access |
| Location (Old Town / Duval) | Foot of Duval Street with private beach access and waterfront dining | Top of Duval Street and Mallory Square, steps from waterfront attractions |
| Size (rooms) | 142 guest rooms & suites (119 rooms + 23 suites) | 100 individually decorated guestrooms |
| Ages / audience | Family-friendly; children of all ages welcome (check-in age 24) | Open to all ages (not adults-only) |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool and whirlpool hot tub (fenced, family-friendly) | One outdoor pool with poolside bar and free pool cabanas |
| Beach / waterfront access | Private white-sand beach on site | Direct Old Town waterfront location (beach access/public waterfront) |
| Restaurants & bars | Multiple venues: One Duval (oceanfront), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café | Two restaurants, three bars/lounges and a poolside bar |
| Spa & wellness | Pier House Spa — roughly 10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, steam room, Vichy showers, fitness center | Full-service spa available on site (size not published) |
| Event & meeting space | Around 2,600 sq ft of meeting space including a 2,000 sq ft ballroom and several outdoor venues | About 870 sq ft of conference/meeting space (1 meeting room) |
| Notable for | Private beach, historic Chart Room Bar, large spa facilities | Sunset-facing rooms near Mallory Square and Duval Street nightlife |
Pier House sits at 1 Duval Street at the foot of Duval with direct access to its private white-sand beach and waterfront restaurants.
Pick Pier House if you want beach access plus Old Town attractions a short walk away.
Ocean Key Resort occupies a waterfront spot at the top of Duval Street, seconds from Mallory Square and the waterfront action.
Choose Ocean Key for the most central, sunset-facing Old Town location.
Pier House offers a wider mix of room types and larger suites suitable for families and groups.
Better choice for families or travelers who want spacious suites and multiple bed options.
Ocean Key has about 100 individually decorated guestrooms with a focus on ocean or harbor views and a compact, intimate layout.
Good pick if you want a boutique-feeling stay with sunset- and harbor-view room options.
Pier House has a range of dining from casual beach fare to an oceanfront fine-dining room.
Pier House suits guests who want on-site variety from casual to more formal waterfront dinners.
Ocean Key concentrates on a smaller set of restaurants and several bars, geared toward waterfront dining and drinks.
Ocean Key is for travelers who prefer a compact set of well-placed dining and bar options right on the waterfront.
Pier House pairs a heated outdoor pool and whirlpool with its private white-sand beach.
If a private beach matters, Pier House is the clear choice.
Ocean Key offers an outdoor pool plus direct Old Town waterfront frontage—it’s a social, sunset-oriented pool scene.
Ocean Key works well if you want a lively pool scene and immediate waterfront access to Mallory Square.
Pier House highlights a full-service spa and a historic bar that’s been part of Key West’s music scene for decades.
Pier House is best for guests who want on-site spa services plus relaxed evening bar options rooted in Key West history.
Ocean Key provides a full-service spa and several bars that focus on waterfront sunset and evening socializing.
Ocean Key is geared toward sunset-watching and waterfront nightlife with spa access for relaxation.

Pier House — on-site private white-sand beach for sunbathing and direct ocean access.

Pier House — a roughly 10,000 sq ft Pier House Spa with 10 treatment rooms and multiple hydrotherapy features.

Ocean Key — steps from Mallory Square and at the top of Duval Street for evening activity and sunset viewing.

Ocean Key — a smaller, boutique-feeling property with many rooms oriented toward harbor or ocean views.
Pier House is more family-focused (children of all ages welcome, family-sized suites, fenced heated pool and private beach).
Both are within a very short walk; Ocean Key sits at the top of Duval and is closest to Mallory Square, while Pier House is at the foot of Duval with beachfront access.
Yes—both properties have rooms with private balconies; Ocean Key highlights sunset-facing rooms and Pier House has oceanfront suites with balconies.
Pier House — the Pier House Spa is listed at roughly 10,000 sq ft with 10 treatment rooms; Ocean Key has a full-service spa but the listing does not publish a size.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·