
Pier House Resort & Spa
Best for travelers who want to be steps from Duval Street, Old Town attractions, and a full-service spa on site.
Prices in other currencies are estimates. You’re charged in USD.
Pier House Resort & Spa is a four-star, family-friendly oceanfront resort at the foot of Duval Street with a private white-sand beach and a large on-site spa; this guide is for travelers who want Old Town access plus beach and spa facilities. Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection is a historic four-star oceanfront resort on a broader beachfront under Hilton’s Curio brand; this is for travelers who want a branded, beachfront property with conference and meeting facilities.
Updated · about 1.2 km apart

Best for travelers who want to be steps from Duval Street, Old Town attractions, and a full-service spa on site.

Best for travelers who want a historic, branded oceanfront resort with more meeting space and multiple pools.
When Pier House Resort & Spa wins: choose Pier House if you want immediate Old Town access (Duval Street, Mallory Square) combined with a private white-sand beach and a large dedicated spa facility for treatments.
When Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection wins: pick Casa Marina if you prefer a larger beachfront resort owned by a major brand, need more meeting/conference space, or want multiple on-site pools and a broad slate of water-sport options.
Bottom line: both are four-star oceanfront Key West resorts with beach access and strong name recognition. Pier House is the better choice for Old Town location, waterfront dining, and a dedicated spa experience; Casa Marina is better if you want a larger property footprint, Curio/Hilton benefits, and more conference or pool capacity.
| Category | Pier House Resort & Spa | Casa Marina Key West, Curio Collection |
|---|---|---|
| Overall vibe | Old Town beach resort with a mix of historic bars, waterfront dining and resort facilities | Historic oceanfront Curio property with broad beachfront grounds and larger meeting facilities |
| Location | At 1 Duval Street, footsteps from Duval Street and Mallory Square | 1500 Reynolds Street on Key West’s oceanfront (Higgs/South Beach area), about 1.2 km from Duval |
| Size (rooms) | 142 rooms and suites (119 guest rooms and 23 suites listed) | 311 rooms |
| Ages / policy | Family-friendly, children of all ages welcome; primary guest must be at least 24 to check in | All-ages property (not adults-only); primary check-in age 21 on supplier listing |
| Pools | Heated outdoor pool plus whirlpool; fenced family-friendly pool open dawn to dusk | Two outdoor pools and a private beach; wheelchair-accessible pool and pool hoist available |
| Restaurants & bars | Several on-site venues: One Duval (oceanfront dinner), Three Palms Beach Bar, Chart Room Bar, Harbour View Café | One on-site restaurant and a bar/café options (Morrison’s Market, coffee shop/cafe, beach bar) and room service with limited hours |
| Spa & wellness | Pier House Spa — roughly 10,000 sq ft, 10 treatment rooms, steam room, Vichy showers, spa treatments for 14+ | Full-service spa on site (services include massages, facials and body treatments); Not published |
| Meeting & events | Smaller meeting footprint with several function rooms and ballrooms (Grand Cayman Ballroom 2,000 sq ft) | Extensive conference space (7 meeting rooms, about 976 m² / 10,504 sq ft of meeting space) |
| Beach | Private white-sand beach on site | |
| Brand/loyalty | Independent/resort (not part of a major global brand) | Hilton Curio Collection — Can earn/use Hilton points |
Pier House sits at One Duval Street, immediately at the foot of Duval and a short walk to Mallory Square and Old Town attractions.
Choose Pier House if you want to be in the center of Old Town with immediate access to restaurants and nightly entertainment.
Casa Marina sits on Reynolds Street with a broader oceanfront site and private beachfront near Higgs and South Beach areas of Key West.
Choose Casa Marina if you want a larger beachfront property and don’t need to be right on Duval Street.
Pier House offers a range of coastal-styled rooms and suites, many with balconies and waterfront views.
Pier House is good for travelers who want Old Town proximity with the option of oceanfront rooms or larger suites.
Casa Marina lists a broad set of room types and more total rooms across the property.
Casa Marina suits travelers who want more room-type choices and larger overall inventory at a branded hotel.
Pier House centers dining around several distinct venues including an oceanfront signature restaurant and a historic bar.
Pier House offers more distinct on-site dining atmospheres (fine-dining, casual beach bar, historic bar) without leaving the property.
Casa Marina has restaurant and bar options on site, plus a market/cafe and limited room service.
Casa Marina provides beachfront dining and café options, and works well for travelers who want on-site convenience with brand standards.
Pier House combines a private white-sand beach with a heated outdoor pool and whirlpool.
Pier House is the pick if you want a private beach and a single, family-friendly heated pool in the heart of Old Town.
Casa Marina emphasizes broader beachfront grounds with multiple outdoor pools and beach access.
Casa Marina is better if you want more pool variety and a larger beachfront layout for sunbathing and water activities.
Pier House’s spa is a major on-property attraction; nightlife access is immediate via Duval Street.
Choose Pier House if an in-depth spa program and instant Old Town nightlife access matter most.
Casa Marina provides on-site spa services and a quieter beachfront evening setting with Curio/Hilton brand support.
Casa Marina fits travelers who want branded-collection amenities and a resort-evening feel rather than being in the middle of Duval nightlife.

Pier House — located at the foot of Duval Street and a short walk to Mallory Square and Old Town attractions.

Pier House — a roughly 10,000 sq ft Pier House Spa with 10 treatment rooms and multiple signature treatments.

Casa Marina — far more meeting space (7 meeting rooms and roughly 10,504 sq ft / 976 m² of conference space).

Casa Marina — bigger room inventory and multiple outdoor pools across a broader oceanfront footprint.
Pier House — it sits at the foot of Duval Street; Casa Marina is a short walk or shuttle ride away (about 1.2 km).
Pier House publishes a roughly 10,000 sq ft spa with 10 treatment rooms; Casa Marina has an on-site full-service spa but published size/room count is Not published.
Yes — both hotels have private beachfront access.
Casa Marina has more total meeting space and multiple meeting rooms; Pier House has intimate waterfront terraces and ballrooms for smaller weddings and events.
Explore how Pier House Resort & Spa stacks up against other hotels nearby:
vs. sites like Expedia, Hotels.com and other OTAs ·